Nestled among Kentucky's rolling hills and bourbon distilleries, Bardstown's charm earned it the title "America's Most Beautiful Small Town" in 2012. Yet behind this picturesque facade lurks a darker reality—five unsolved murders that have traumatized the community and left families searching for answers for over a decade.

At the heart of this mystery is Crystal Rogers, a devoted mother of five who vanished without a trace on July 3, 2015. Her abandoned car discovered on the Bluegrass Parkway—keys, purse, and phone still inside—was just the beginning of a saga that would expose a complex web of family ties, police corruption, and small-town secrets. When Crystal's father Tommy Ballard began getting too close to the truth during his relentless search for his daughter, he too was silenced—shot dead while hunting with his grandson 16 months after Crystal disappeared.

The 2025 trials finally brought some justice, with Crystal's boyfriend Brooks Houck receiving a life sentence for her murder. His employees, Stephen and Joseph Lawson, were also convicted for their roles in the conspiracy. Testimony revealed chilling details—discussions about using farm hogs to dispose of a body, suspicious tampering with evidence, and the hasty sale of a car where cadaver dogs later detected human remains. Yet despite these convictions, Crystal's body remains missing, and several alleged conspirators—including Brooks' brother Nick, a former police officer, and their mother Rosemary—haven't faced charges.

Perhaps most troubling is the connection to other Bardstown tragedies. Police Officer Jason Ellis was ambushed and killed on the same parkway in 2013. The Netherland mother and daughter were brutally murdered in 2014. Investigators hint at connections between all these cases but haven't revealed how they intersect.

Meanwhile, Crystal's young son remains in the custody of the Houck family—the very people implicated in his mother's murder—creating another painful chapter for her grieving family. As pink ribbons continue to flutter throughout Bardstown, they serve as reminders of the justice that remains incomplete.

What twisted motivations led to these crimes? How deeply do the connections run through this small Kentucky community? And will Crystal's remains ever be found to give her family the closure they desperately seek?

Do you want to advertise with 69 SOUTH?

Call Bulldog Roofing Company for all of your homes roofing needs. 317-996-7663

Scented Jewels
We’ve got the coolest wax melts ever. Dive into a world of many aromas at shopscentedjewels.com

Bulldog Roofing Company
Roofing Specialist 317-996-7663 , 317-996-ROOF

Rosie's Posys Farmstand
Sourdough, Sweets, and Flowers at 6082 E. Hadley Rd., Moorseville, IN

Disclaimer: This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase, I may receive a commission at no extra cost to you.

Support the show

Disclaimer: All defendants are INNOCENT UNTIL PROVEN GUILTY in a court of law. All facts are alleged until a conviction!